Like Kevin Drum, I'm not sure what to make of this compromise that averts the nuclear option on filibusters for now. On the face of it, Democrats agreed to let up-or-down votes happen for three nominees, none of whom are shining lights of jurisprudence. That seems like a loss. But the reaction from the religious right is such (Gary Bauer calls it a sellout; James Dobson calls it a complete bailout and betrayal) that it may be a victory at least in the Pyrrhic sense. If you want to see the document, here's Page 1, and here's Page 2. If you like hyperbole, Crooks and Liars has a slew of quotes from all sides.
Posted by Linkmeister at May 24, 2005 12:01 AMI think this is an Unvarnished Good Thing for the Republic.
Posted by: NTodd at May 24, 2005 03:30 AMI think the extremists on both sides lose in this deal, which is a good thing, IMO
Posted by: Pixelshim at May 24, 2005 05:02 AMYes, it's a Good Thing for the Republic, but if you've seen Episode III, you know what the Republic became...
Posted by: Keith at May 24, 2005 12:15 PMAlas, no. A terrible deal, and not much of a compromise for the Democrats. More accurately, I'd call it capitulation.
Please see my lengthier comments here:
http://the-reaction.blogspot.com/2005/05/democrats-cave-no-filibuster-for.html
and:
http://the-reaction.blogspot.com/2005/05/i-say-nuclear-you-say-nucular-lets.html
Yes, watch the Republic become a decadent, quasi-totalitarian Empire. Right under our very noses...